The book of abraham also introduced the first and only scriptural basis for denying the priesthood to blacks, the churchs official position until 1978. Latter day saints, dictated what he claimed was a translation of an ancient egyptian papyrus containing the writings of abraham. The problem is that when higher quality photos came out, the vignette showed those tips were open lines. Why doesnt the translation of the egyptian papyri found in 1967. Ritners response to the book of abraham essay general.
Singles, young adults, and men especially those who did not serve a mission seem to be among the most likely demographics of people who leave the lds church. The professor holds a phd in the field of ancient scripture and provided the following response. They are now referred to as the joseph smith papyri. In addition, a lot of the concepts about the world come from thomas dicks philosophy of a future state 1830 and thomas taylors the six books of proclus on the. Mormon missionaries who come to your door will be stunned when you bring up the problem with the book of abraham.
The book of abraham papyri were thought to have been lost in the 1871 great chicago fire. For many, the book of abraham is problematic, a real shelfbreaker. Why doesnt the translation of the egyptian papyri found in. There are a lot of resources giving the orthodox lds response to the boa issue. It is evident that the writings of abraham while he was in egypt, of which our printed book of abraham is a copy, must of necessity be older than. Egyptian papyri and the book of abraham religious studies. Abraham 1 recirculates the bibles curse of ham story, which was popularly interpreted in josephs time by many christians as justification for. Those facsimiles are still in the pearl of great price with the incorrect translations attached, and if youve never read dr.
Others have heard of a tension but are unaware of its magnitude. Official church response to book of abraham problems. Just this last week, the church reemphasized the importance of its new essays in addressing thorny doctrinal topics. Yet, the latterday saint view of the work is never given a clear airing. The book of abraham is a work produced between 1835 and 1842 by joseph smith based, he said, on egyptian papyri purchased from a traveling mummy exhibition. A brief overview of the book of abraham problem truth is.
I saw this on my facebook feed, curious is people have seen this yet, it is a response by robert ritner specifically to the lds gospel topics essay on the book of abraham. The recent web posting on the book of abraham by the church of jesus christ of latterday saints hereafter the lds church represents new reflection on a document whose authenticity as verifiable history is now officially acknowledged to be in serious dispute. Feb 01, 2014 for an indepth analysis regarding the implausibility of the book of abraham being true, see this article. This ensign article is the closest thing to an official response to the problems with the book of abraham. For example, in an article previously on the byu site and linked from here with the title criticisms of joseph smith and the book of abraham, there is a very weak rebuttal to the charge that. For a more contextual explanation, see part 2 of the gentle awakening presentation series. This page deals primarily with the question of the source of the book of abraham now available online at lds. The lds reaction to these issues is confined to a few citations in the section on the. The book of abraham is easily the most esoteric book in the latterday saint canon. Quote with the book of abraham now confirmed as a perhaps wellmeaning, but erroneous invention. The book of abraham is not central to the restored gospel of christ. On september 9, 2014 the church of jesus christ of latterday saints sent a letter to all priesthood leaders.
The papyri in question are a part of the collection of egyptian mummies and. The lds church has done its best to respond to two difficult problems with the book of abraham papyri. First, the association of facsimile 1 with the book of abraham cannot derive from abraham, since facsimile 1 dates to approximately 100 b. Translation and historicity of the book of abraham the university. Continue to an open response to an apologists explanation of the book of abraham problem.
Through the years, whenever the book of abraham was printed there were included with the printed text three drawings, each designated as a facsimile from this alleged book of abraham. Official response of the mormon church to the book of abraham. Critical appraisal of the book of abraham wikipedia. About that joseph smith video response to new lds video on joseph smith. There are passages in the text of the book of abraham which are attributed to abraham and which refer to facsimile 1 abr. The letter instructed priesthood leaders to send doubting or inquisitive members to a series of essays recently published in the gospel topics section of. The dishonesty of mormon apologetics on facts are the problem obfuscation is the strategy. Jan 24, 2017 just this last week, the church reemphasized the importance of its new essays in addressing thorny doctrinal topics. Translation and historicity of the book of abraham a. Mormon handbook the book of abraham since abraham lived before moses, who authored the torah the first five books of the old testament, it would make the papyrus older than the book of genesis.
Ritners response to lds statement on the book of abraham sign in to follow this. There are a few hieratic symbols that will not display properly on most browsers. An open response to an apologists explanation of the book of. The essays seek to explain the events in an easy to understand format for both members of the church and other individuals that may be interested in mormon history. Both lds and nonlds scholars agree the pieces of papyrus scroll we have today were those possessed by joseph smith and used to produce the book of abraham. In just words we explain the problems with joseph smith and the book of abraham and then detail why the lds apologetic responses.
Religious studies center, brigham young university. It was released by the church to help explain how the book of mormons credibility is not harmed due to recent dna evidence which concludes that the native americans are not the descendants of the book of mormon people, and to explain why the churchs credibility is not harmed due to having such a. The dishonesty of mormon apologetics on facts are the. Ritners response to lds statement on the book of abraham. Below is a summary of quotes from the article, with my. F or many mormons, an examination of the book of abraham and its true history becomes the most significant stumbling block to joseph smiths claim as a prophetic translator of ancient languages. Recently, i was forwarded a response received by a concerned member who wrote his byu professor of ancient scripture regarding the book of abraham problem. As you most certainly know, the mormon apologists cannot adequately answer the criticisms of the book of abraham.
Singles, young adults, and men especially those who did not serve a mission seem to be among the most likely demographics of people who leave. My latest read was an ldsrelated book, john gees newly published an introduction to the book of abraham salt lake city and provo, ut. Thousands of years ago, the prophet nephi learned that one purpose of the book of mormon was to establish the truth of the. Mormon and nonmormon egyptologists agree that the characters on the fragments do not match the translation given in the book of abraham, though there is not unanimity, even among nonmormon scholars, about the proper interpretation of. What do you think of the lds churchs book of abraham. For example, in an article previously on the byu site and linked from here with the title criticisms of joseph smith and the book of abraham, there is a very weak rebuttal to.
One possible problem notes that the book of abraham translation apparently references the book of breathings made by isis, linking the text of the book of abraham not to an abrahamic record on the scrolls but, mistakenly, to the first vignette page 97 of the book of breathings. The book of abraham has a lot of problems, but it is necessary to note that the apocryphal books of jasher and josephus are used for concepts in the book. Consider the footnote in the essay on the book of abraham that was recently exposed for being a deliberate and outright sham of context. While translating the book of mormon, he used the urim and thummim rather. I will include an open response to his explanation. More book of abraham problems seymour bloom writes. For the wikipedia article on the subject, see this link. The veracity and value of the book of abraham cannot be settled by scholarly debate concerning the books translation and historicity, a new lds church essay concludes. Jeremy runnells and the book of abraham rational faiths. Translation and historicity of the book of abraham response.
October 29, 2019 thank you, president nelson byu speech on lgbt policies. Mar 25, 2016 for christians abraham preludes christs sacrifice, a notion we as lds share, but we stress abraham more than most of our coreligionists. For christians abraham preludes christs sacrifice, a notion we as lds share, but we stress abraham more than most of our coreligionists. What if joseph smith translated the book of abraham similar to the book of mormon or the parts of the bible such as the book of moses, without.
And he gets right down to the real problem, while the lds essay didnt even mention the facsimiles. My primary concern is that the views of both sides of the issue regarding the boas accuracy and authenticity taint the core articles objectivity. One major reason is of course the book of abraham, allegedly translated from an egyptian papyrus, but better viewed as an independent revelation. Translation and historicity of the book of abraham a response. The following essay is the official lds released essay entitled book of mormon and dna studies. The book of abraham is a work produced between 1835 and 1842 by the latter day saints. Outright dishonesty in lds essay on book of abraham.
For an indepth analysis regarding the implausibility of the book of abraham being true, see this article. A positive identification is possible because one of the rediscovered scroll pieces, now called papyrus joseph smith 1 pjs 1, matches the picture in the book of abraham called facsimile. The book of abraham narrative clearly demonstrates the manner in which the lds church works diligently to massage or reinterpret inconvenient facts to continue to defend its. Lds church publishes new web essay on book of abraham. See brian hauglid, the book of abraham and muslim tradition, in astronomy, papyrus, and covenant, studies in the book of abraham, vol. Professor ritners response originally appeared as a pdf document on the universitys oriental institute website. Attempts by mormons to answer the book of abraham problem fail. The book of abraham also introduced the first and only scriptural basis for denying the priesthood to blacks the authors of mormonthink makes the following claim. My addition on book of abraham content something jeremy didnt include, but something i think is kind of a big deal is some of the content in the book of abraham that is the justification for some of the racist cultural attitudes of the past. However, in 1966 several fragments of the papyri were found in the archives of the metropolitan museum of art in new york and in the lds church archives.
Mormon and non mormon egyptologists agree that the characters on the fragments do not match the translation given in the book of abraham. Some are completely unaware that such a problem exists. The above donut chart shows percentages of the book of abraham section of letter to a ces director that fairmormon is in agreement, disagreement, and neutral on if one assumes that fairmormons undisputed silence is acceptance of the facts, fairmormon agrees with 90. The gospel topic page addresses all of these difficult issues. The lds church has done its best to respond to two difficult problems with the book of abraham. According to smith, the book was a translation of some ancient records. The book of abraham, found in the pearl of great price, is considered to be canonical by the lds church.
The original context was demonstrating joseph smith to be a. The book of abraham papyri a half century later today is the 50th anniversary of the dramatic front page of the november 27th 1967 deseret news, revealing that the lds church had received from the metropolitan museum of art some of the original papyri of joseph smiths book of. Many of the essays address controversial issues from the churchs history. Ritner, a leading egyptologist at the university of chicago and an expert on the joseph smith papyri, responds to the 2014 article on the book of abraham that appeared on the lds churchs official website. Abraham refers to a picture in the text of the book of abraham abr. More book of abraham problems seymour bloom writes as you most certainly know, the mormon apologists cannot adequately answer the criticisms of the book of abraham. The lds church admits on their website that the book of abraham is not a translation of the papyri joseph claimed it was a translation of. Robert ritners lds apologist john gees professor response to the abraham essay, please do so because its from a respected egyptian scholar we wont even go into the outside sources joseph smith used to write the book of abraham or how the printers block. Feb 05, 2014 recently, i was forwarded a response received by a concerned member who wrote his byu professor of ancient scripture regarding the book of abraham problem. Mormon essays publishes links to the recent essays written by the church of jesus christ of latterday saints, or the mormon church. Part 2 deals with the content of the book and joseph smiths comments on three egyptian drawings that have been attached to the published book of abraham. One that you can find frequently in lists made by critics of the church is the validity of the book of abraham as found in the pearl of great price, part of the. A response to translation and historicity of the book of abraham by dr robert ritner. In other words, it was a common breathing permit that the egyptians buried with their dead.
My latest read was an lds related book, john gees newly published an introduction to the book of abraham salt lake city and provo, ut. Smith who had claimed to have translated the book of mormon from golden. Debunking fairmormon letter to a ces director book of. How the book of abraham exposes the false nature of mormonism. The book of abraham is a work produced between 1835 and 1842 by joseph smith based. Professor ritner lds egyptologist john gees former professor has given his response to the lds church essay on the book of abraham. If the papyri were the record of abraham while he was in egypt, they would be the oldest extant manuscript of biblical material. This is a remarkable statement in view of the fact that nonmormon egyptologists who have commented on joseph smiths interpretation of the. This book is aimed for a broad audience with an interest. Kerry muhlestein, egyptian papyri and the book of abraham.
How the book of abraham exposes the false nature of. This would weaken the likelihood of the book of abrahams also. One major reason is of course the book of abraham, allegedly translated from an egyptian. This time, the church responded by reiterating that the book of mormon was divinely inspired, and that the book of abrahams source papyri likely. The book of abraham is a book of lds scripture that joseph smith translated from a collection of ancient egyptian papyri the church purchased. Mormon and nonmormon egyptologists agree that the characters on the fragments do not match the translation given in the book of abraham, though there is not unanimity, even among nonmormon scholars, about the proper interpretation of the vignettes on these fragments. September 18, 2019 doubts are not dangerous theyre necessary september 17, 2019 the book of abraham in 1,000 words august 26, 2019. Translation and historicity of the book of abraham. Objections to the book of abraham latterday commentary. Apr 08, 2008 objections to the book of abraham my focus over the last dozen posts has been in answering, even if only for myself, some of the more common objections to lds doctrine or practices. We print the response below in its entirety below from signature books.
The lds essay historicity of the book of abraham presents a number of problematic arguments and citations taken out of context. Objections to the book of abraham my focus over the last dozen posts has been in answering, even if only for myself, some of the more common objections to lds doctrine or practices. May 15, 2017 the dishonesty of mormon apologetics on facts are the problem obfuscation is the strategy. Criticism of mormonismwebsitesmormonthinkthe book of abraham. In the entry on the facsimiles from the book of abraham in the encyclopedia of mormonism we are told that the prophets explanations of each of the facsimiles accord with present understanding of egyptian religious practice. Mormon and nonmormon egyptologists agree that the characters on the fragments do not match the translation given in the book of abraham. The former reorganized church of jesus christ of latter day saints, since 2001 renamed the community of christ, avoids this issue by treating the book of abraham as. Text from kep matches book of abraham verses actual egyptian meaning 1. The papyri are not old enough to be what joseph claimed, and they dont say what joseph claimed. Abraham refers to a picture in the text of the book of abraham, and this picture is presumed to be the one we call facsimile one.
Criticism of mormonismwebsitesmormonthinkthe book of. The hypocephalus in question was prepared for an individual named sheshonq. The book of abraham is a sacred text to the latterday saints, in the same way the koran is to moselms. An open response to an apologists explanation of the book. In the last chapter, we saw some of the problems mormonism faces with the book of mormon and archaeology.
The church promptly appeals to ignorance, as its second introductory paragraph, falsely suggests no eyewitness account of the translation survives, making it impossible to reconstruct the process. The churchs essay on this topic attempts to reconcile the problematic nature of the book of abrahams origin with the doctrinal importance of its contents. Criticism of mormonismonline documentsletter to a ces. Maintaining the divine authority of the book of abraham is every bit as vital to the doctrines and theology of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints today as it was in the days of joseph smith, brigham young and their successors. The author notes that, egyptologists have found the source material for the book of abraham to be nothing more than a common pagan egyptian funerary text for a deceased man named hor in 1st century ad. Why doesnt the translation of the egyptian papyri found. The book of abraham issues translation problems mormonthink. Latterday saints can learn more accurate and pertinent data and information in 2 hours of reading both the churchs translation and historicity of the book of abraham essay and dr. Ritners direct response than they would in several weeks of mining through obfuscated unofficial mormon apologetic materials. This page deals primarily with the question of the source of the book of abraham now available online at.
In a nutshell, fragments of the papyri joseph used in his translation of the boa were discovered in 1967, and upon inspection by competent egyptologists, the characters turn out to have little to do with the text of the book of abraham. Below is a summary of quotes from the article, with my comments in parenthesis. Deseret book and byu religious studies center, 2017. Ritner 5 early mormonism and the magic world view, 244. Its the only lds scripture that includes graphical images. None of the characters on the papyrus fragments mentioned abrahams name or any of the events recorded in the book of abraham. Dec 23, 2015 both lds and non lds scholars agree the pieces of papyrus scroll we have today were those possessed by joseph smith and used to produce the book of abraham. A faithful, egyptological point of view, in no weapon shall prosper.
374 710 708 1608 51 1560 1456 971 461 1353 200 196 573 42 526 1364 8 88 1028 747 455 1595 1185 732 37 412 275 1573 1072 770 1630 170 661 16 406 960 917 1219 920 638 940 1267 861 1359 1090 1165 1312 1241